The Paradox of Winning: Coaching Youth Football Beyond the Scoreboard

Join the Coaching Circle

Join our free email group, the Coaching Circle, and never miss out on valuable coaching tips and resources. Stay updated with the latest posts, news, and exclusive offers available only to Coaching Circle members.

After a pre-season drubbing with my under 15s on the weekend, I was somewhat aggressively posed a question by a quizzical young player on our bench. We had conceded multiple times from direct, long ball tactics that were highly effective against us, primarily due to the disparity between the growth stages of each team. At half time we had spoken about not getting sucked into long ball football, but rather attempt to relax on the ball, play to feet, and aim to retain possession.

The question posed was “Why don’t we just play long ball direct football? look how great it works!”

It’s really a question that’s not just about tactics or style of play but about the very essence of what we aim to achieve as volunteer coaches guiding young athletes. It’s about the sacrifice of quality football and player development for the immediate gratification of winning games through direct, long ball tactics.

The conventional wisdom suggests that the objective of any game is to win. Yet, when coaching youth football, is victory in the current game worth the potential sacrifice of long-term player development? This is not a question of whether winning matters, but rather, what are we truly aiming to win?

Possession-based, team football tactics focus on the intricacies of the game: passing, movement, spatial awareness, and strategic play. They teach young players not just how to play, but how to think, react, and work together as a cohesive unit. This approach molds well-rounded footballers equipped with a rich skill set and an intimate understanding of the game’s nuances.

On the other hand, a direct, kick-and-run strategy, while perhaps more likely to secure a win in youth leagues, emphasises less on skill development and more on exploiting the physical disparities that often exist among young players. It’s a tactic that may win games but at what cost to player development?

The question then arises: Are we, as coaches, prioritizing the short-term triumphs over the long-term growth and enjoyment of our players?

Imagine a generation of players raised solely on the principles of direct football. They may miss out on developing critical skills and understandings of the game that would make them versatile, intelligent players in their adult years. Is the fleeting joy of a weekend win worth this potential outcome?

But let’s dive deeper. Why do we coach? Is it to see our team’s name at the top of the local youth league table, or is it to instil a love for the game, teamwork, discipline, and a broad array of footballing skills in our young players?

The impact of our coaching philosophy extends far beyond the pitch. It’s about shaping individuals who can think, adapt, and thrive in both football and life. Does the real victory lie not in the score at the final whistle but in the journey and growth of our players?

As volunteer coaches, we’re in a unique position to influence the future of the sport and the young individuals entrusted to our guidance. It’s worth pondering: What legacy do we want to leave in the hearts and minds of our players? Are we building teams that win games, or are we developing players who love the game, understand it deeply, and will play it beautifully and intelligently for a lifetime?

In the end, perhaps the most profound victories are those achieved off the scoreboard, in the growth, development, and joy of our players. As we reflect on our coaching philosophies, let’s ponder the legacy we’re creating, one pass, one game, one young player at a time.

Pocket Coaching Cards

Build a training session for kids aged 5 to 9 in just 1 minute. Choose a green, a yellow and a red card and you have a structured, age appropriate, engaging and fun training session ready to run.

Join the Coaching Circle

Join our free email group, the Coaching Circle, and never miss out on valuable coaching tips and resources. Stay updated with the latest posts, news, and exclusive offers available only to Coaching Circle members.